Jimmy Doherty’s final BBC programme “A Farmer’s Life For Me” concluded last week with Ray and Jane, one of the nine original couples taking the 25 acre farm for a year. The program covered a variety of farming aspects looking predominantly at animals and poultry but also covering important husbandry aspects of the land.
In many ways it was a land based version of The Apprentice with Jimmy acting more as a tutor than Sir Alan Sugar and Paul Kelly playing the part of Margaret, sorry Karen, no Nick Hewer! As a first series I thought it did a good job in showing the contestants how hard they were going to have to work and making them work together to win the tasks.
In many ways this is where The Apprentice falls down due to the contestants backing away from the teamwork ethos in an attempt to score points over others in their team yet here each couple needed to think through strategies together before implementing them.
The winners were also a bit of a surprise as they had started badly and not been widely seen as winning material. They were also not the best team at coming up with ideas for the required products yet had spade loads of some extremely important attributes; hard work and application. In the final this paid off well for them in the penning and splitting of the sheep.
Whilst both teams made some mistakes in this part of the task a more methodical approach paid off while Ian and Sue tried to be too careful and took far too long to get the job done. Each week Ian and Sue did extremely well in coming up with ideas for products and the required marketing of them but in the final they relied too heavily on one product to carry them through.
This was where Ray and Jane struggled a little. To be fair there was always pressure on them to achieve and many of the couples had difficulty in coming up with new ideas. It’s easy for us at home to criticise but I know how difficult I would find it to put ideas on a clean sheet of paper in so little time with so much riding upon it.
Having won the competition that pressure releases somewhat and allows time for them to complete things and top and tail ideas properly. What the show did do was set out a number of things that can be extremely valuable for small businesses.
1 Planning is vital.
When we undertake audits nearly a third of the time is spent in planning the job properly. Whilst this is probably more time than in other fields planning can often be overlooked with people piling in to the task without any idea how it is all going to come together.
The three semi finalists suffered this on the strawberry picking challenge when they all got excited at early sales and took their eye off the picking part of the task. Furthermore why did all the men get put in charge of the van and delivering the product?
At the end of the day delivery, whilst important, is a straight forward process and had the men stayed behind they might have driven on their pickers harder by leading from the front in short bursts. That’s not to say that the ladies could not do that but they didn’t until Jimmy gave them an appropriate ticking off.
2. Get the balance right by decision making
People are always frightened about making a bad decision yet a bad decision is one that has been taken and can often be changed. Fear is a terrible thing and fear of failure can freeze a decision making process.
Yet we don’t seem to get trained to make decisions at all and consequently often we take too long to arrive at one if we do at all. In one episode fireman Dean spent forever looking at his computer in search of a font leading to a niggly argument with his partner.
Yet Dean was brilliant in an early show when he came across a fire at a farm and assisted in putting it right. He took loads of decisions then but probably didn’t think he made any as he just went into overdrive and took control of the situation.
3. Agree Jobs
It sounds too easy to say but planning should provide this so that everyone knows what they are doing. All too often a person can lead and have everyone else watching them work. If it ends up like this then there is no teamwork and consequently the time – in this case was halved – or can be extended dreadfully if it is a task that needs to be completed. In these reality shows the task is incomplete and risks your future in the program but in real terms work will get put back and risks overtime costs.
4. Break down your time
We all underestimate our time when we plan a job because we cannot appreciate just how long things will take. Blank canvas jobs are a real time sapper so you need, if you can, to look at other aspects which can be planned to work back to what you might have available for them.
5. Work hard on your costs
The secret to most business success is buying well. If you can do this then you give yourself more chance of a better margin. In these programs it is surprising how bullish people are in what they can sell only to immediately cave in when the selling process begins. Taking a more cautious approach is often the best way.
6. Bear in mind what you are working with
In this case it was animals and we all know how challenging they can be. In the final both couples forgot the effect we humans have on them and the sheep became terrified and at risk to injury. Unfortunately easy mistakes to make by the inexperienced.
7. Some business experience is essential
Yet how do we get this? It is difficult talking to experienced traders like Jimmy and Paul about unit sales and margins when you have never done it before. Ian and Sue were in a better position to do this than Ray and Jane from their previous jobs and after poor sales on the tasks they were concerned to overestimate and end up with waste.
Interestingly in both couples the women were the driving force. Certainly Sue was the brains of the unit and often allowed Ian to do other things while she got on with it and at their final interview he pushed the figures over to her. For the winners Jane was the more vocal but got involved in all of the tasks supporting Ray really well on the physical aspects. They appeared to have no business experience at all from their previous lives and have a lot to learn but have proved throughout the series that they are willing to listen and learn.
The program has a winning formula and like Adam’s Farm on Countryfile showed us the general public a lot of information about how the industry works. As we know at Lambert Chapman LLP showing how things work in agriculture is no bad thing for us the public to see so that we can feel comfortable with the processes adopted and look out for products that might have passed us by had we not been shown them.
Jimmy has certainly grown into a mature presenter and in this series he sometimes struggled to deal with the sending home as he had got to know the contestants and knew how keen all were to live the dream. He also had a good rapport with Paul Kelly throughout and got all of the experts talking to the camera so that the information came across.
I would hope that Jimmy visits Ray and Jane throughout their year to see how they are getting on though with the move to Channel 4 this might not be possible. We all appreciate a unit of this size will be difficult to make money from but we also know Ray and Jane will put in all the effort needed to try and make it happen.